Like our site? Get our monthly newsletter!

The most honest art gallery in the world.

Highlights

Why Classical Natural Oil Paints Surpass Modern Synthetics: A Painter’s Perspective on Hue, Value, Chroma, and More

19th Century Fine Art Legacy

In the golden age of realism—from the late 18th to the early 20th century—painters like Bouguereau, Gérôme, and Sargent created masterpieces of lifelike clarity and glowing atmosphere. A central element in their technique was the paint itself: classical natural oil paint, made with hand-ground pigments suspended in cold-pressed linseed, walnut, or poppy oil. Today’s mass-produced synthetic oil paints, often filled with stabilizers, alkyds, and petroleum-derived materials, may offer convenience and shelf stability, but in terms of artistic quality, they fall short in key ways.

Let’s explore why classical natural oil paint remains unmatched, particularly through the essential aspects of painting: hue, value, chroma, temperature, opacity, tinting strength, and realistic rendering.

Hue: The Soul of Color

Natural pigments—such as vermilion, madder lake, natural ultramarine, and genuine Naples yellow—offer hues that modern synthetics struggle to replicate. Their hues are often subtler and more complex, containing delicate undertones that interact richly with light. For example, natural ultramarine, made from lapis lazuli, has a violet undertone that modern synthetic versions often lack. This subtlety enhances realism, especially in skin tones, skies, and atmospheric effects.

By contrast, synthetic hues are typically more chemically pure, which can make them appear garish or overly “clean” in mixtures, especially under indirect light.

Value: Control Through Transparency

Value—how light or dark a color appears—is crucial for shaping form. Classical paints tend to have greater transparency or subtle semi-opacity, allowing painters to control value through thin layering (glazing) techniques. Many 19th-century works achieve glowing lights not by white paint, but by layered transparent color over a light ground.

Modern synthetic paints, especially those loaded with titanium dioxide or fillers, can behave more opaquely, limiting value transitions and making form harder to model delicately. This can flatten the image, leading to a more graphic or posterized look.

Chroma: Saturation in Balance

Chroma, or the intensity of a color, is where natural pigments shine. Earth pigments like raw sienna or green earth never “shout”—they are naturally low-chroma but retain an earthy elegance. Natural bright pigments, like cochineal-based carmine or genuine vermilion, glow without overwhelming the eye.

Synthetic paints often have unnaturally high chroma, which can be tempting for beginners. However, when mixed, these synthetic brights can muddy quickly or dominate a composition, making subtle chromatic shifts much harder to control. Natural pigments tend to mix more gracefully, yielding subtle color interactions ideal for realism.

Temperature: The Play of Warm and Cool

Temperature shifts—warm vs. cool—are essential for modeling light and shadow. Natural pigments have asymmetric, nuanced temperature shifts. A natural umber, for instance, might warm slightly in the lights and cool in the shadows, depending on the medium and ground.

Synthetic colors often have less temperature complexity, requiring additional effort to create naturalistic effects. They may also lack the unique temperature "bias" found in older pigments, like lead-tin yellow (warm, glowing) or genuine indigo (cool, soft).

Opacity: Layering and Luminosity

Classical oil painters exploited the varying opacity of pigments to create depth. Lead white, for instance, is semi-opaque and luminous, allowing underlayers to glow through in highlights. Earth pigments like ochres are gently opaque, making them perfect for flesh and fabric.

Modern titanium white is highly opaque and cold, often killing the luminosity of underlying layers. Many synthetic pigments are either too opaque (flattening space) or unnaturally transparent (failing to cover or unify), making them less responsive to traditional layering techniques.

Tinting Strength: Controllability Matters

Natural pigments usually have moderate tinting strength, which gives artists more control in mixing and shifting hues without overpowering the palette. This helps especially in fine flesh modeling or subtle transitions.

Synthetic pigments like phthalo blue or quinacridone magenta have extremely high tinting strength—a tiny amount can overpower a mixture. While this can be useful, it requires much more experience to handle well, and often leads to frustration or unexpected color shifts.

Realistic Painting: The Final Word

Ultimately, all the above properties matter because they serve the goal of realism. The old masters achieved a lifelike softness, atmosphere, and luminosity rarely seen in contemporary painting. Much of that came from technique—but technique relies on materials that respond with finesse. Natural oil paints allow for:

  • Subtle transitions in tone and color
  • Depth through glazes and scumbles
  • Accurate atmospheric and flesh effects
  • Harmonious palettes that echo nature

Modern synthetic paints may suit expressive, graphic, or abstract styles—but for classical realism, they often fight against the painter. Classical oil paints, though more demanding and sometimes harder to obtain, reward the artist with a palette that breathes with life, giving form to the highest traditions of visual art.

Conclusion

Classical natural oil paints aren't just a nod to tradition—they are tools designed for mastery. With superior hue subtlety, balanced chroma, manageable tinting strength, and natural opacity, they offer qualities that modern synthetics simply can't replicate. For those dedicated to realism and subtle beauty, returning to the materials of the 19th century is not nostalgic—it's a serious artistic upgrade.

Back to Highlights

Jerry & Joan - Thanks for your hospitality and helping us find this beautiful new piece for our home. Until next time...

Adrienne & Jon W.
We accept:

230 South Juliana St.
Bedford PA 15522

Phone: 724-459-0612

All content and photos are copyrighted property of Bedford Fine Art Gallery, 19th century art dealer, Bedford PA and can not be reproduced or copied without consent.

Unsubscribe from our mailing list Privacy